NEW CHESS THEORY

NCT VIII - CONTROL AND DOMINATION II


We use here the expression «Control and Domination» to express the following simple idea: to arrive at the checkmate, ultimate goal of a chess game, it is appropriate to dominate his adversary. One can thus consider that the "domination" is, for a chessplayer, a good intermediate objective.
Now, we show here that the quality of the "control", exerted on the chessboard, is a decisive element to succeed in the domination. Remarks and considerations on this subject, constituting the present chapter, have been presented for the first time in 2002 («Courrier des échecs» 522, october 2002, p.289 to 294)
In this second chapter dedicated of the study of "Control and Domination", we mainly examine, through two exemplary games, the evolution of White and Black Radiation Rates (RR), like its geometrical translation on corresponding cartographies of the chessboard.


NCT VIII-A - Evolution of the RR
- In a game Kramnik-Topalov -
(World Championship, Elista 2006)



We select now a chess game of the recent World Chess Championship Match: Topalov - Kramnick, where we will examine attentively the "evolution" of the "Radiation rate" of both players.

  • World Chess Championship Match:
    Topalov - Kramnick
      -   Game No 9 -

  • Topalov, Veselin (2813)-Kramnik, Vladimir (2743)
    - (D12) semi-slav, 1-0, Elista (RUS) 2006 -


         1.d4    d5
         2.c4    c6
         3.Nf3    Nf6
         4.e3    Bf5
         5.Nc3    e6
         6.Nh4    Bg6


    This line of the Semi-Slav is well known and was many often played since the game Esser, Johannes-Van Foreest, Arnold E 0-1 (D12), Amsterdam 1911.

    DIAG 1 :


    The cartography of this position is the following:


    In this conditions we have the numerical values:

    | W | = 29
    | B | = 31
    | Y | = 1
    | R | = 3


    Of this values we immediately deduce the "Radiation rates":

      WRR  =   100  x   29 / (64  -  4)   %   =  48   %
      BRR   =   100  x   31 / (64  -  4)   %   =  52   %


    In the present case these technical results have only a limited interest. They show however that each camp remains rather monolithic and, in addition, that the combat is not yet really engaged. But it is equally interesting to remark the strong influence of the Black Bishop g6 (red squares b1 and c2) and the resulting light Black domination.

         7.Nxg6    hxg6
         8.a3    Nbd7
         9.g3!?N A novelty    Be7
         10.f4    dxc4
         11.Bxc4    0-0
         12.e4 Pawn-front   b5
         13.Be2    b4!?


    9.g3!? seems to be a novelty. Has been explored: 9.h3 Be7 10.Bd3 0-0 11.0-0 e5 12.cxd5 cxd5 13. dxe5 Nxe5 14.Bb1 Rc8 = Finegold, Benjamin (2539) - Zaremba, Andrie (2342) 1-0 (D12) Philadelphia World op 2003.

         14.axb4    Bxb4
         15.Bf3    Qb6
         16.0-0    e5!  d4 pinned
         17.Be3    Rad8
         18.Na4! Initiative ...


    It is rather clear that Kramnik created, since 13... b4!?, a strong pressure on white central pawns. But Topalov found a positional play which enables him to resist and gradually to arrive to a certaine initiative. The present position deserves our attention:

    DIAG 2 :


         18...    Qb8
         19.Qc2    exf4
         20.Bxf4 Initiative    Qb7  Defensive
         21.Rad1    Rfe8
         22.Bg5! Initiative Be7  Defensive
         23.Kh1 Prophylaxy ...


    Topalov reaches a good initiative. Was equally playable: 23.Kg2 Nb6 24.Nc5 Bxc5 25.Qxc5 Na4 26.Qc2 Qxb2 27.Rf2 Qxc2 28.Rxc2 c5!? 29.e5 Nd5 30.Ra1 Nac3 with a clear White advantage.

    DIAG 3 :


         23...    Nh7?!  Doubtful
         24.Be3    Bg5
         25.Bg1! Accurate    Nhf8  Recycling
         26.h4! Initiative Be7
         27.e5 Domination Nb8  Defensive


    Topalov obtains this time a dominant position of which we will examine carefully the characteristics:

    DIAG 4 :


    The cartography of this position is as follows:


    In this conditions we have the numerical values:

    | W | = 32
    | B | = 27
    | Y | = 3
    | R | = 2


    Of this values we immediately deduce the "Radiation rates":

    WRR  =   100  x   32  / (64  -  5)   % =  54   %
    BRR   =   100  x   27  / (64  -  5)   % =  46   %


    Kramnik is now on the defensive and, except fault of White, it will be difficult for him to find a valuable counterplay.

         28.Nc3    Bb4
         29.Qg2! Interesting Qc8
         30.Rc1    Bxc3
         31.bxc3 Pawn-chain    Ne6
         32.Bg4 Pin move    Qc7 Unpin move   
         33.Rcd1    Nd7 Recycling
         34.Qa2    Nb6 Recycling
         35.Rf3 Logical Nf8? A fault


    35...Nf8? is a very surprising fault. After: 35...Nd5 36.Rdf1 Rd7 37.c4 Nb6 38.Rd1 Qb7 the White advantage is not decisive and Black can continue the combat.

         36.Rdf1!    Re7
         37.Be3! The best Nh7 Defensive
         38.Rxf7!    Nd5 Obstruction
         39.R7f3!? (39.Be6!!)    1-0


    The stronger White retort was here: 39.Be6!! with the foreseeable continuation: 39...Kh8 40.Bg5 Ndf6 41.exf6 Rxf7 42.Bxf7 gxf6 43.Bf4 + - and White wins easily.

    DIAG 5 :



    The cartography of this final position is thus the following one:



    In this "Cartography of the DIAG 5" it is instructive to note some examples. In particular the pinned Knight d5 does not control any square:

  • a6 is White:    fcW(a6) = 1 > fcB(a6) = 0
  • d6 is White:    fcW(d6) = 3 > fcB(d6) = 2
  • e6 is Red:    fcW(e6) = 1 = fcB(e6) = 1
  • d5 is Black:    fcW(d5) = 1 < fcB(d5) = 3
  • f6 is White:    fcW(f6) = 5 > fcB(f6) = 4
  • e4 is Yellow:    fcW(e4) = 0 = fcB(e4) = 0


  • In this case we have the numerical values:

    | W | = 36
    | B | = 23
    | Y | = 2
    | R | = 3


    Of this values we immediately deduce the "radiation coefficients":

    WRR  =   100  x   36 /   (64  -  5)   % =  61   %
    NRR   =   100  x   23  /   (64  -  5)   % =  39   %



    NCT VIII-B - Evolution of the RR
    - In a correspondence game -



    We select now an interesting correspondence chess game where we will examine attentively the "evolution" of the "Radiation rate" (RR).

  • Hervet, Gilles (France) - Kotrc, Michal (Czechoslovakia) B12 (48) 1-0, corr, ICCF, EU/M/GT/399, 1994     (Caro-Kann, Advance variation)

         1.e4    c6
         2.d4   


    This advance of the d-pawn is unquestionably the most popular answer facing the Caro-Kann. Nevertheless, interesting is the "two Knights variation" : 2.Nc3 d5 3.Nf3 played by Fischer against Petrossian in 1959, during the Candidats Tournament; Fischer expresses the idea that the move Bf5 is then doubtful.

         2...    d5
         3.e5   


    An important crossroads of the Caro-Kann. In addition to the "advance variation" 3.e5 played here, you may choose the "exchange variation" 3.exd5 cxd5 or the classic answer 3.Nc3. More precisely we have the choice between:

  • The Panov-Botvinnik Attack:   3.exd5 cxd5 4.c4
  • The Classical Variation:   3. Nc3 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Bf5
  • The Smyslow System:   3. Nc3 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Nd7
  • The Larsen System:   3. Nc3 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Nf6!? 5.Nxf6+ gxf6


  •      3...    Bf5
         4.Nc3   


    A flexible answer leading to many lines:


    DIAG 6 :


    More usual is the continuation:   4.Nf3 e6 5.Be2 c5 6.0-0 Nc6 7.Be3 cxd4 (Vogt, Lothar (2510) - Kasparov, Garry (2595) ½-½ (B12) Baku, 1980). Is now, in fact since 1981, rather popular the suite:   4.c3 e6 5.Be3 Nd7 (Galstian, Beniamin (2448) - Amini, Amer (2267) 1-0 (B12) IRI-chT Iran, 2005).

         4...    e6  
         5.g4 Only way!  Bg6   Be4?
         6.Nge2 Accurate    f6?!  Doubtful


    According to Giogaze this move meets less and less, in current practice. More popular is today: 6...c5 7.h4 h5!? 8.Nf4 +/= (Karpov, Anatholy (2715) - Ludin, A 1-0 (B12) Zuerich sim, 1998). May be also considered: 6...Ne7; for example: 7.Nf4 c5 8.h4 cxd4 9.Nb5 Nec6 10.h5 Be4 11.f3 Bxf3 12.Qxf3 Nxe5 13.Qg3 Nbc6 14.Nd3 Nxd3+ 15.Bxd3 e5= (Lautier, Joel (2630) - Karpov, Anatoly (2760) 0-1 (B12) Amber-Rapid 6th, 1997).

         7.Nf4  (7.h4!?)  fxe5!?   (Bf7!) 
         8.dxe5    Bf7    
         9.Qe2    Nd7    
         10.Bd2N  Novelty  ...    


    10.Bd2 was a novelty in 1994, played by our friend Gilles Hervet. Since, this move was seldom selected and we know only two or three examples; in particular: 10.Bd2 Qc7 11.0-0-0!? (Lukacs) 0-0-0 12.Re1 Bc5! (Lukacs: with the idea: Bd4) 13.h4 Bd4 14.Nd3 h5! (Lukacs) = (Nataf, Igor Alexandre (2559) - Najer, Evgeniy (2606) ½-½ (B12) EU-ch 4th Istambul, 2003).

         10...    Qc7 Aiming d5
         11.Nd3    Ne7    
         12.0-0-0  Thematic  Ng6 Black pressure
         13.f4! +/= Be7   Development 
         14.h4 Idea: h5 0-0-0?   A fault 
         14.h5 Logical Ngf8   Forced
         16.Bg2! Initiative ...    


    DIAG 7 :


    White has good prospects for attack on the King side, whereas Black does not have a clear counter play.

    The cartography of this position is as follows:


    In this "Cartography of the DIAG 7" it is instructive to note some examples. In particular the pinned Knight d5 does not control any square:

  • a8 is Yellow:    fcW(a8) = 0 = fcB(a8) = 0
  • d6 is White:    fcW(d6) = 3 > fcB(d6) = 2
  • d5 is Black:    fcW(d5) = 2 < fcB(d5) = 7
  • e5 is White:    fcW(e5) = 5 > fcB(e5) = 2
  • f5 is Red:    fcW(f5) = 3 = fcB(f5) = 3
  • g3 is Yellow:    fcW(g3) = 0 = fcB(g3) = 0


  • In this conditions we have the numerical values:

    | W | = 30
    | B | = 28
    | Y | = 4
    | R | = 2


    Of this values we immediately deduce the "Radiation rates":

    WRR  =   100  x   30  / (64  -  6)   % =  52   %
    BRR   =   100  x   28  / (64  -  6)   % =  48   %


    Each camp remains rather monolithic and the combat is not yet really engaged. However the White game is already dominating. Notice that each side must watch over in particular the yellow squares located in its territory, which are vulnerable points.

         16...    Nc5!? Doubtful
         17.Nxc5  Logical  Bxc5    
         18.Be3!  Bad Bishop  Nd7
         19.Bxc5! +/- Nxc5 Active Knight


    DIAG 8 :


    It is often an error, of the weakest camp, to believe that exchanges will relieve its position; here the white position is reinforced. One can add all the same that is not better: 16...g6 17.hxg6 (17.h6 Nb6 18.g5 Nc4) Bxg6 18.Kb1 Kb8 19.Be3 +/-. In clear Black does not have any more good prospects.

         20.Rhf1! Idea: f5 Nd7 Defensive
         21.Qf2 With threat  Kb8   (Nb6!?) 
         22.Rd4!? Risked  Rhf8?! (g5!)
         23.Qg3!? +/= Rde8?! (Nb6)


    DIAG 9 :


    22.Rd4 is a relatively flexible move, played with the idea to double the Rooks later on; but it is rather risked according to: 22...g5 23.hxg6 Bxg6 24.Bh3 c5! =.

         24.Rhf1! Doubling h6? Passive move
         25.Ne4! Initiative  Nb6 Defensive 
         26.Nd6! Outpost  Re7?! (Rd8)
         27.c4! Break move ...


    DIAG 10 :


    Obviously the White domination is particularly clear; however we judge useful to give a quantified estimate of this "domination" and, at the same time, a descriptive representation of this one.

    The "cartography of the DIAG 10" is as follows:


    In this cartography we may notice some examples:

  • h7 is Yellow:    fcW(h7) = 0 = fcB(h7) = 0
  • d6 is White:    fcW(d6) = 3 > fcB(d6) = 1
  • d5 is Black:      fcW(d5) = 6 < fcB(d5) = 8
  • f6 is Red:         fcW(f6) = 3 = fcB(f6) = 3
  • f5 is White:      fcW(f5) = 4 > fcB(f5) = 3
  • e2 is Yellow:    fcW(e2) = 0 = fcB(e2) = 0


  • In this conditions we have the numerical values:

    | W | = 32
    | B | = 24
    | Y | = 6
    | R | = 2


    Of this values we immediately deduce the "Radiation rates":

    WRR  =   100  x   32  / (64  -  8)   % =  57   %
    BRR   =   100  x   24  / (64  -  8)   % =  43   %


    It is indeed an undeniable "domination". But, however it remains to transform it into victory.

         27... Nxc4?! (Nc8)
         28.Nxc4   dxc4  
         29.Qc3 (29.Bf1)  Ree8
         30.Qxc4 Rd8
         31.Rd6!? (31.Qb4!) ...


    The strongest continuation is certainly : 31.Qb4! Rg8 32.Rd6 Ka8 33.Bf1 (with the idea: Bc4) + -. Any way, White has a significant advantage.

    DIAG 11 :


         31... Rxd6 (Bg8?!)
         32.exd6   Qd7   Blocking 
         33.Be4 (33.Qd4)  e5     (Bg8)
         34.Qc3! Qxg4
         35.Qxe5 Only move Ka8   (Qh4)
         36.d7 Passed pawn Qh4   Forced
         37.Qc7 (37.b4!) Qd8   Forced
         38.Qd6! Initiative Rg8   Defensive



    DIAG 12 :


    This time the "White domination" is impressive and our technical results strengthen widely this opinion:

    The "cartography of the DIAG 12" is as follows:


    In this cartography we may notice some examples:

  • c8 is White:    fcW(c8) = 3 > fcB(c8) = 2
  • e8 is Red:      fcW(e8) = 3 = fcB(e8) = 3
  • c7 is Red:      fcW(c7) = 1 = fcB(c7) = 1
  • g5 is Black:    fcW(g5) = 3 < fcB(g5) = 4
  • h5 is Black:    fcW(h5) = 0 < fcB(h5) = 1
  • a4 is Yellow:   fcW(a4) = 0 = fcB(a4) = 0


  • In this conditions we have the numerical values:

    | W | = 29
    | B | = 21
    | Y | = 10
    | R | = 4


    Of this values we immediately deduce the "Radiation rates":

    WRR  =   100  x   29   / (64  -  14)   % =  58   %
    BRR   =   100  x   21   / (64  -  14)   % =  42   %


    In spite of a strong degradation of the Black situation, one can notice that the "Radiation rates" are near identical to those of the DIAG 10. Hence the "Cartography of the DIAG 12" contains some interesting informations not translated by the RR.

    The end of the game, completely foreseeable, proceeds as follows (the only interrogation is of knowing why Black does not resign earlier):

    39.Bh7 Rg8 40.Bg6 Bxg6 41.Qxg6 Qb8 42.Qxg7! Qxf4+ 43.Kb1 Qf5+ 44.Ka1 Rd8 45.Qe7 Qg5? (Qa5) 46.Qxg5! hxg5 47.Re1! Kb8 48.Re8 1-0

    DIAG 13 :


    ***

    NEW CHESS THEORY :

  • Next chapter :


  • «NCT IX - THE SPECTRUM OF A POSITION I»


  • Back to the menu :


  • ************

       «© Chess-Theory -
    Private Collection»


    ***


    FOR PLEASANT SURFING AROUND THIS SITE:

  • We suggest these best paths:

  •   «LASTEST UPDATES»
      «GENERAL SITE PLAN»
      «GENERAL SITE MENU»
      «LINK COLLECTION HOME PAGE»
      «ECO CODES BASE»
      «CHESS THEORY FORUMS»
      «SEARCH ENGINE»
      «VIRTUAL ART MUSEUM»


    ***


    FOR DISCOVERING WHO WE ARE:

  • ... and also expressing freely your opinion:

  •   «CHESS-THEORY: GUEST BOOK»
      «CHESS-THEORY: ABOUT US»    
      «CHESS-THEORY: COPYRIGHT»





               * DON'T NEGLECT TO CONTACT US HERE! *           
    This page, created by Michel Bruneau, is
    Copyright: © Michel Bruneau «Chess-Theory»
    Webmaster - All rights reserved 2004-2008


    Thank to  you  visitors  and friends!...
    Please notice  that  you  help us a  lot
    by giving your opinion and comments
    about  this  page as well as all  other
    pages that you have recently visited
    in  the   «Chess-Theory»   Website:


      Express yourself
on our Guest Book  

    My Dear  Friends!...  Without  at   least
    your  moral  support, formulated  here
    or   on  our  forums, this  site can close
    definitively without advance warning!
    ... Humour? Maybe, but it is also true
    that   a   Webmaster,  most of  the time
    alone facing his computers, experien-
    ces  sometimes,   in  his  projects  and
    realizations, discouragement and doubt
    ... HELP ME BY WRITING YOUR FEELINGS!


    The «Chess-Theory» Website receives
    more than
    90, 000 different visitors
    per month, coming  from  about
    145
    different   countries   in   the   world
    (daily statistics generated by awstats)






    * «CHESS-THEORY FOUNDATION» WEB SITES *
    The  «Chess-Theory  Foundation»,  currently
    still  unofficial,   under  the  responsibility   of
    Michel Bruneau, the «Chess-Theory»  Web-
    master,   puts   to  your  disposal  the   three
    following   complementary  Web   Addresses:


    * CHESS-THEORY.COM *

    ~ CHESS-THEORY.COM ~
    This is our main site, fully dedicated
    to Chess Theory, Chess Training, Chess
    Analysis and Chess Practice; but presenting
    also the first version of our Virtual Art
    Museum. This bilingual Site owns about 2 000
    English pages, 2 000 French pages, more than
    10 000 linked images, many hundreds of chess
    diagrams and more than 110 analyzed games
    presented with the "Chess-Theory" Viewer!...

                   ~ 'CHESS-THEORY.COM' ~
      This is our main site, fully dedicated 
      to Chess Theory, Chess Training, Chess 
      Analysis and Chess Practice; but presenting
      also the first version of our Virtual Art 
      Museum. This bilingual Site owns about 2 000 
      English pages, 2 000 French pages, more than  
      10 000 linked images, many hundreds of chess 
      diagrams and more than 110 analyzed games    
      presented with the 'Chess-Theory' Viewer!...


    * VIRTUAL-ART-MUSEUM.COM *

    ~ VIRTUAL-ART-MUSEUM.COM ~
    You will recover here, in a surprising
    new look design, all galleries and
    linked images of the "Chess-Theory"
    Virtual Art Museum ... but, rather soon,
    you will discover also many new beautiful
    galleries presenting a rich collection
    of unexpected Hight Definition Images,
    Royalty Free Photos and so more ....

             ~ 'VIRTUAL-ART-MUSEUM.COM' ~
      You will recover here, in a surprising
      new look design, all galleries and
      linked images of the 'Chess-Theory'
      Virtual Art Museum ... but, rather soon,
      you will discover also many new beautiful 
      galleries presenting a rich collection 
      of unexpected  Hight Definition Images, 
      Royalty Free Photos and so more ....


    * FROM-THE-WHOLE-WORLD.COM *

    ~ FROM-THE-WHOLE-WORLD.COM ~
    This Web Site, currently under
    construction, will deal with all
    cultural, intellectual or moral
    subject untreated by other ones

     ~ 'FROM-THE-WHOLE-WORLD.COM' ~
      This Web Site, currently under
      construction, will deal with all
      cultural, intellectual or moral
      subjects not treated by other ones




    «Michel  Bruneau  the  "Chess-Theory" Webmaster
    ...  presumably   when  he  was  a   little  younger
    and    still    full    of    Illusions   and     Dreams! »
    Photograph and Montage by Jean-Pierre Bruneau
    Copyright © 2008 Jean-Pierre Bruneau & "Chess-Theory"
    Nevertheless this image is available for Link Exchange!

         Michel Bruneau the 'Chess-Theory' Webmaster 
         ...presumably when he was a little younger   
                and still full of Illusions and Dreams!


    ******** ©-«Chess-Theory.com»-2004-2008 ********


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    
    Listen Music Now